China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (in force 2022-03-01)

Algorithm filing for services with public-opinion attributes or social-mobilisation capacity, security assessment, display of the filing number, and a user option to switch off personalised recommendation

From clause to evidenceThe chain from China Algo. Rec. CAC Order No. 9 to its evidence record, in 6 steps; the text alternative lists them and the facts under the figure state each in full.Clause: China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (2022), CAC Order No. 9ClauseChina Algo.Rec.CAC Order No. 9Duty holder: not statedDuty holderNot statedApplies from: 2022-03-01 (In force)Applies from2022-03-01In forceArtefact: Algorithm inventory with filing record and number; security-assessment evidence pack; opt-out control at runtimeArtefactAlgorithminventory with…Layers: Layer 01 Govern-as-Code and Layer 02 Inventory & Transparency and Layer 04 Runtime Controls & ObservabilityLayersLayer 01Layer 02Layer 04Evidence record: the common evidence record (Evidence record v1)Evidence recordEvidence recordv1Same topic in 26 frameworks (230 clauses): EU AI Act, ISO 42001, NIST AI RMF, TC260 Framework 3.0, ISO 23894, CSA AICM,Korea AI Act and 19 moreAs of 2026-09-20 · illustrative, not a claim of conformity From clause to evidenceThe chain from China Algo. Rec. CAC Order No. 9 to its evidence record, in 6 steps; the text alternative lists them and the facts under the figure state each in full.Clause: China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (2022), CAC Order No. 9ClauseChina Algo. Rec. · CAC Order No. 9Duty holder: not statedDuty holderNot statedApplies from: 2022-03-01 (In force)Applies from2022-03-01 · In forceArtefact: Algorithm inventory with filing record and number; security-assessment evidence pack; opt-out control at runtimeArtefactAlgorithm inventory with filing…Layers: Layer 01 Govern-as-Code and Layer 02 Inventory & Transparency and Layer 04 Runtime Controls & ObservabilityLayersLayer 01Layer 02Layer 04Evidence record: the common evidence record (Evidence record v1)Evidence recordEvidence record v1Same topic in 26 frameworks (230 clauses):EU AI Act, ISO 42001, NIST AI RMF, TC260Framework 3.0, ISO 23894 and 21 moreAs of 2026-09-20illustrative, not a claim of conformity
From clause to evidence Build the artefact, then file every output it produces as a record that names AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC. Drawn from chapter 08.
Text alternative
  • Clause: China Algo. Rec., CAC Order No. 9.
  • Duty holder: Not stated.
  • Applies from: 2022-03-01, In force.
  • Artefact: Algorithm inventory with filing….
  • Layers: Layer 01, Layer 02, Layer 04.
  • Evidence record: Evidence record v1.
  • Record schema: Evidence record.
  • The same topic in 26 other frameworks; the crosswalk section below links each clause.
When this obligation appliesThe date of AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC on a time axis, against its review date 2026-09-20.Earlier2024202620282030As of 2026-09-202022-03-01 · In forceBinding; in force2022-03-012022-03-01 · In force · Binding; in force 2022-03-01Source: Obligation register(chapter 08)
When this obligation appliesThe date of AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC on a time axis, against its review date 2026-09-20.2022-03-01 · In forceBinding; in force 2022-03-012024202620282030EarlierAs of 2026-09-202022-03-01 · In force · Binding; in force 2022-03-01Source: Obligation register (chapter 08)
When this obligation applies The first date in the row's status, then each later step: filled once its date has passed, outlined while it is still ahead of the review date.
Data table: the dates
Dates of AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC
DateStepDetail
2022-03-01In forceBinding; in force 2022-03-01
Id
AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC
Instrument
China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (2022) law
Clause
CAC Order No. 9
Applies from
In force · Binding; in force 2022-03-01

The artefact that evidences it

Algorithm inventory with filing record and number; security-assessment evidence pack; opt-out control at runtime.

What this obligation connects toChina Algo. Rec. CAC Order No. 9 and its 26 relations: 26 same crosswalk topic.DirectChina Algo. Rec. CAC Order No. 9Same crosswalk topic (26)AI Verify 4.3.1, 4.7.1, 4.2.1, 9.1.1, 9.5.2, 1.1.6, 1.7.2, 1.1.1, 9.12.1, 5.5.1, 10.3.1, 10.3.2, 9.4.1, 4.8.1, 9.5.4, 1.5.1, 1.6.1, 5.11.1, 7.1.1, 7.2.1, 7.8.1, 2.2.1, 1.1.4 · Core clauseAI VerifyCSA AICM GRC-02, MDS-12, GRC-01, GRC-06, MDS-03, MDS-04, STA-08, IAM-03, GRC-15, TVM-13, AIS-09, AIS-10, SEF-07, SEF-08, GRC-11, GRC-13, GRC-14 · Core clauseCSA AICMChina AI Labelling Label Art. 4, Label Art. 5 · Core clauseChina AI LabellingChina Deep Synthesis DeepSyn Art. 7, DeepSyn Art. 16, DeepSyn Art. 17, DeepSyn Art. 19, DeepSyn Art. 10 · Core clauseChina Deep SynthesisChina GenAI Measures GenAI Art. 17, GenAI Art. 9, GenAI Art. 12, GenAI Art. 19, GenAI Art. 10, GenAI Art. 14, GenAI Art. 15, GenAI Art. 4(2) · Core clauseChina GenAI MeasuresCoE Convention CoE Art. 16, CoE Art. 9, CoE Art. 14(2), CoE Art. 15(2), CoE Art. 8, CoE Art. 10 · Core clauseCoE Convention+20 more+20 more: EU AI Act Art. 9, Art. 3, Art. 17, Art. 4, Art. 87, Art. 11, Art. 13, Art. 53, Art. 50, Art. 86, Art. 18, Art. 43, Art. 53(1)(d), Art. 50(2), 50(4), Art. 49, Art. 71, Art. 6, Art. 3(1), Art. 52, Art. 14, Art. 26, Art. 14(4)(b), Art. 5, Art. 15, Art. 5(1)(a)–(b), Art. 72, Art. 73, Art. 26(5), Art. 55, Art. 3(49), Art. 20, Art. 10(2)(f)–(g), Art. 4a, Art. 13(3)(b)(iv)–(v), G7 Code G7 Action 5, G7 Action 3, G7 Action 2, G7 Action 4, GAO AI Accountability 1.6, 1.2, 1.1, 1.3, 1.9, 3.5, 1.7, 3.1, 3.9, 4.1, 4.2, 2.7, 3.8, GDPR Art. 5(2), Arts. 13–14, Art. 30, Art. 22, Arts. 33–34, Art. 5(1)(a), Art. 9, Art. 15(1)(h), Art. 13(2)(f), Art. 22(3), GPAI Code Safety C1, Safety C3, Safety C8, Transparency 1.1, Transparency 1.2, Safety C5, Safety C9, Safety 3.5, ISO 23894 23894 6.4, 23894 6.5, 23894 6.6, ISO 42001 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 8.2, 8.3, A.6, 6.1.4, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, A.2, A.3, 9.3, 7.2, 9.2, 10.1, 7.5, A.8, A.4, A.9, 10.2, A.5.4, A.8.2, Korea AI Act Art. 34(1)(1), Art. 36, Art. 31, Art. 34(1)(2), Art. 33, Art. 34(1)(4), Art. 32(1), NIST AI RMF MAP 1, MAP 5, MANAGE 1, GOVERN 1.3, MAP 1.5, MANAGE 1.3, MANAGE 1.4, MEASURE 3, MEASURE 2, GOVERN 1, GOVERN 2, GOVERN 4, GOVERN 5, MEASURE 2.8, MAP 1.6, MEASURE 2.9, GOVERN 1.6, GOVERN 1.7, MANAGE 2.4, MAP 3.5, GOVERN 3.2, MANAGE 2, MANAGE 4, MANAGE 4.3, GOVERN 4.3, MEASURE 2.11, GOVERN 3.1, OECD AI Principles OECD 1.5(c), OECD 1.5, OECD 1.3, OECD 1.2(b), OECD 1.2, OWASP LLM LLM01:2026, LLM10:2026, LLM06:2026, Singapore Agentic Agentic 2.1, Agentic 2.2.1, Agentic 2.2.2, Agentic 2.3.1, Agentic 2.3.3, Singapore GenAI GenAI 1, GenAI 3, GenAI 4, TC260 Framework 3.0 TC260 2, TC260 Summary table, TC260 5.3.19, TC260 4, TC260 5.3.12, TC260 App. 2 II.2, TC260 4.4.1, TC260 App. 2 II.3, TC260 App. 2 II.5, TC260 3.2.1, TC260 5.3.7, TC260 5.3.18, TC260 App. 2 II.6, UK ATRS ATRS 2.5.2, ATRS 2.1, ATRS Tier 1, ATRS 2.2, ATRS 2.3.2, ATRS 2.4.2, ATRS 2.3.5, UK DUAA UK GDPR Art. 22C, prEN 18228 prEN 18228, EN 18286 EN 18286, GB/T 45654 GB/T 45654 Content labelling, OWASP Agentic ASI09
What this obligation connects toChina Algo. Rec. CAC Order No. 9 and its 26 relations: 26 same crosswalk topic.DirectSame crosswalk topic (26)AI Verify 4.3.1, 4.7.1, 4.2.1, 9.1.1, 9.5.2, 1.1.6, 1.7.2, 1.1.1, 9.12.1, 5.5.1, 10.3.1, 10.3.2, 9.4.1, 4.8.1, 9.5.4, 1.5.1, 1.6.1, 5.11.1, 7.1.1, 7.2.1, 7.8.1, 2.2.1, 1.1.4 · Core clauseAI VerifyCSA AICM GRC-02, MDS-12, GRC-01, GRC-06, MDS-03, MDS-04, STA-08, IAM-03, GRC-15, TVM-13, AIS-09, AIS-10, SEF-07, SEF-08, GRC-11, GRC-13, GRC-14 · Core clauseCSA AICMChina AI Labelling Label Art. 4, Label Art. 5 · Core clauseChina AI LabellingChina Deep Synthesis DeepSyn Art. 7, DeepSyn Art. 16, DeepSyn Art. 17, DeepSyn Art. 19, DeepSyn Art. 10 · Core clauseChina Deep SynthesisChina GenAI Measures GenAI Art. 17, GenAI Art. 9, GenAI Art. 12, GenAI Art. 19, GenAI Art. 10, GenAI Art. 14, GenAI Art. 15, GenAI Art. 4(2) · Core clauseChina GenAI MeasuresCoE Convention CoE Art. 16, CoE Art. 9, CoE Art. 14(2), CoE Art. 15(2), CoE Art. 8, CoE Art. 10 · Core clauseCoE Convention+20 more+20 more: EU AI Act Art. 9, Art. 3, Art. 17, Art. 4, Art. 87, Art. 11, Art. 13, Art. 53, Art. 50, Art. 86, Art. 18, Art. 43, Art. 53(1)(d), Art. 50(2), 50(4), Art. 49, Art. 71, Art. 6, Art. 3(1), Art. 52, Art. 14, Art. 26, Art. 14(4)(b), Art. 5, Art. 15, Art. 5(1)(a)–(b), Art. 72, Art. 73, Art. 26(5), Art. 55, Art. 3(49), Art. 20, Art. 10(2)(f)–(g), Art. 4a, Art. 13(3)(b)(iv)–(v), G7 Code G7 Action 5, G7 Action 3, G7 Action 2, G7 Action 4, GAO AI Accountability 1.6, 1.2, 1.1, 1.3, 1.9, 3.5, 1.7, 3.1, 3.9, 4.1, 4.2, 2.7, 3.8, GDPR Art. 5(2), Arts. 13–14, Art. 30, Art. 22, Arts. 33–34, Art. 5(1)(a), Art. 9, Art. 15(1)(h), Art. 13(2)(f), Art. 22(3), GPAI Code Safety C1, Safety C3, Safety C8, Transparency 1.1, Transparency 1.2, Safety C5, Safety C9, Safety 3.5, ISO 23894 23894 6.4, 23894 6.5, 23894 6.6, ISO 42001 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 8.2, 8.3, A.6, 6.1.4, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, A.2, A.3, 9.3, 7.2, 9.2, 10.1, 7.5, A.8, A.4, A.9, 10.2, A.5.4, A.8.2, Korea AI Act Art. 34(1)(1), Art. 36, Art. 31, Art. 34(1)(2), Art. 33, Art. 34(1)(4), Art. 32(1), NIST AI RMF MAP 1, MAP 5, MANAGE 1, GOVERN 1.3, MAP 1.5, MANAGE 1.3, MANAGE 1.4, MEASURE 3, MEASURE 2, GOVERN 1, GOVERN 2, GOVERN 4, GOVERN 5, MEASURE 2.8, MAP 1.6, MEASURE 2.9, GOVERN 1.6, GOVERN 1.7, MANAGE 2.4, MAP 3.5, GOVERN 3.2, MANAGE 2, MANAGE 4, MANAGE 4.3, GOVERN 4.3, MEASURE 2.11, GOVERN 3.1, OECD AI Principles OECD 1.5(c), OECD 1.5, OECD 1.3, OECD 1.2(b), OECD 1.2, OWASP LLM LLM01:2026, LLM10:2026, LLM06:2026, Singapore Agentic Agentic 2.1, Agentic 2.2.1, Agentic 2.2.2, Agentic 2.3.1, Agentic 2.3.3, Singapore GenAI GenAI 1, GenAI 3, GenAI 4, TC260 Framework 3.0 TC260 2, TC260 Summary table, TC260 5.3.19, TC260 4, TC260 5.3.12, TC260 App. 2 II.2, TC260 4.4.1, TC260 App. 2 II.3, TC260 App. 2 II.5, TC260 3.2.1, TC260 5.3.7, TC260 5.3.18, TC260 App. 2 II.6, UK ATRS ATRS 2.5.2, ATRS 2.1, ATRS Tier 1, ATRS 2.2, ATRS 2.3.2, ATRS 2.4.2, ATRS 2.3.5, UK DUAA UK GDPR Art. 22C, prEN 18228 prEN 18228, EN 18286 EN 18286, GB/T 45654 GB/T 45654 Content labelling, OWASP Agentic ASI09China Algo. Rec.CAC Order No. 9
What this obligation connects to Solid edges are direct relations, dashed ones looser (a case that cites the same article, a framework whose clauses only touch the topic); patterns and controls take the colour of their stack layer. Select a node to open it; the lists below give every relation in full.
Data table: every relation
Relations of AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC
FamilyItemRelation
Same crosswalk topicAI Verify 4.3.1, 4.7.1, 4.2.1, 9.1.1, 9.5.2, 1.1.6, 1.7.2, 1.1.1, 9.12.1, 5.5.1, 10.3.1, 10.3.2, 9.4.1, 4.8.1, 9.5.4, 1.5.1, 1.6.1, 5.11.1, 7.1.1, 7.2.1, 7.8.1, 2.2.1, 1.1.4Core clause
Same crosswalk topicCSA AICM GRC-02, MDS-12, GRC-01, GRC-06, MDS-03, MDS-04, STA-08, IAM-03, GRC-15, TVM-13, AIS-09, AIS-10, SEF-07, SEF-08, GRC-11, GRC-13, GRC-14Core clause
Same crosswalk topicChina AI Labelling Label Art. 4, Label Art. 5Core clause
Same crosswalk topicChina Deep Synthesis DeepSyn Art. 7, DeepSyn Art. 16, DeepSyn Art. 17, DeepSyn Art. 19, DeepSyn Art. 10Core clause
Same crosswalk topicChina GenAI Measures GenAI Art. 17, GenAI Art. 9, GenAI Art. 12, GenAI Art. 19, GenAI Art. 10, GenAI Art. 14, GenAI Art. 15, GenAI Art. 4(2)Core clause
Same crosswalk topicCoE Convention CoE Art. 16, CoE Art. 9, CoE Art. 14(2), CoE Art. 15(2), CoE Art. 8, CoE Art. 10Core clause
Same crosswalk topicEU AI Act Art. 9, Art. 3, Art. 17, Art. 4, Art. 87, Art. 11, Art. 13, Art. 53, Art. 50, Art. 86, Art. 18, Art. 43, Art. 53(1)(d), Art. 50(2), 50(4), Art. 49, Art. 71, Art. 6, Art. 3(1), Art. 52, Art. 14, Art. 26, Art. 14(4)(b), Art. 5, Art. 15, Art. 5(1)(a)–(b), Art. 72, Art. 73, Art. 26(5), Art. 55, Art. 3(49), Art. 20, Art. 10(2)(f)–(g), Art. 4a, Art. 13(3)(b)(iv)–(v)Core clause
Same crosswalk topicG7 Code G7 Action 5, G7 Action 3, G7 Action 2, G7 Action 4Core clause
Same crosswalk topicGAO AI Accountability 1.6, 1.2, 1.1, 1.3, 1.9, 3.5, 1.7, 3.1, 3.9, 4.1, 4.2, 2.7, 3.8Core clause
Same crosswalk topicGDPR Art. 5(2), Arts. 13–14, Art. 30, Art. 22, Arts. 33–34, Art. 5(1)(a), Art. 9, Art. 15(1)(h), Art. 13(2)(f), Art. 22(3)Core clause
Same crosswalk topicGPAI Code Safety C1, Safety C3, Safety C8, Transparency 1.1, Transparency 1.2, Safety C5, Safety C9, Safety 3.5Core clause
Same crosswalk topicISO 23894 23894 6.4, 23894 6.5, 23894 6.6Core clause
Same crosswalk topicISO 42001 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 8.2, 8.3, A.6, 6.1.4, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, A.2, A.3, 9.3, 7.2, 9.2, 10.1, 7.5, A.8, A.4, A.9, 10.2, A.5.4, A.8.2Core clause
Same crosswalk topicKorea AI Act Art. 34(1)(1), Art. 36, Art. 31, Art. 34(1)(2), Art. 33, Art. 34(1)(4), Art. 32(1)Core clause
Same crosswalk topicNIST AI RMF MAP 1, MAP 5, MANAGE 1, GOVERN 1.3, MAP 1.5, MANAGE 1.3, MANAGE 1.4, MEASURE 3, MEASURE 2, GOVERN 1, GOVERN 2, GOVERN 4, GOVERN 5, MEASURE 2.8, MAP 1.6, MEASURE 2.9, GOVERN 1.6, GOVERN 1.7, MANAGE 2.4, MAP 3.5, GOVERN 3.2, MANAGE 2, MANAGE 4, MANAGE 4.3, GOVERN 4.3, MEASURE 2.11, GOVERN 3.1Core clause
Same crosswalk topicOECD AI Principles OECD 1.5(c), OECD 1.5, OECD 1.3, OECD 1.2(b), OECD 1.2Core clause
Same crosswalk topicOWASP LLM LLM01:2026, LLM10:2026, LLM06:2026Core clause
Same crosswalk topicSingapore Agentic Agentic 2.1, Agentic 2.2.1, Agentic 2.2.2, Agentic 2.3.1, Agentic 2.3.3Core clause
Same crosswalk topicSingapore GenAI GenAI 1, GenAI 3, GenAI 4Core clause
Same crosswalk topicTC260 Framework 3.0 TC260 2, TC260 Summary table, TC260 5.3.19, TC260 4, TC260 5.3.12, TC260 App. 2 II.2, TC260 4.4.1, TC260 App. 2 II.3, TC260 App. 2 II.5, TC260 3.2.1, TC260 5.3.7, TC260 5.3.18, TC260 App. 2 II.6Core clause
Same crosswalk topicUK ATRS ATRS 2.5.2, ATRS 2.1, ATRS Tier 1, ATRS 2.2, ATRS 2.3.2, ATRS 2.4.2, ATRS 2.3.5Core clause
Same crosswalk topicUK DUAA UK GDPR Art. 22CCore clause
Same crosswalk topicprEN 18228 prEN 18228Core clause
Same crosswalk topicEN 18286 EN 18286Related clause
Same crosswalk topicGB/T 45654 GB/T 45654 Content labellingRelated clause
Same crosswalk topicOWASP Agentic ASI09Related clause

Patterns that build it

No pattern in the catalogue names this clause on its "Maps to" line yet; the artefact above is the engineering answer.

The same topic in other frameworks

From the topic crosswalk: the clauses filed under the same topics as this one. Mappings are illustrative, not a claim of conformity.

Risk management

Governance and accountability

Documentation and transparency

Inventory and registration

Human oversight

Runtime guardrails

Incident response and monitoring

Fairness and non-discrimination

Explainability and right to explanation

Source

Chapter 08, section China, checked against its sources on the review date above.

Machine-readable

Cite this obligation

García Aibar, J. (2026). China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (in force 2022-03-01) (AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC). In AI Governance Engineering: The Thesis & Body of Knowledge (v0.5.0). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22956197. https://aigovernanceengineer.com/obligations/aige-obl-cn-algorec. CC BY 4.0

BibTeX

@misc{aige2026obligation,
  author       = {Jorge García Aibar},
  title        = {{China Provisions on Algorithmic Recommendation (in force 2022-03-01) (AIGE-OBL-CN-ALGOREC)}},
  howpublished = {In AI Governance Engineering: The Thesis \& Body of Knowledge},
  year         = {2026},
  version      = {0.5.0},
  doi          = {10.5281/zenodo.22956197},
  url          = {https://aigovernanceengineer.com/obligations/aige-obl-cn-algorec},
  note         = {Version 0.5.0}
}